Strength & Conditioning for the Operational Athlete
https://tacticalbarbell.com/forum/
ml1985 wrote:Sorry for bumping this thread... Currently doing BB and I have a 60 minute run planned this evening, but I’m considering rucking instead. Does rucking achieves the same results as a LSS run (assuming my long term goals are improving my 1.5 mile and 5K run)?
The same results? No. If you want to get better at running in the most efficient way possible, you have to run. Rucking will have some carryover. It's certainly better than not training. In terms of general fitness, rucking is just another training stimulus. Use it if it helps you get where you want to go. But you want to run a fast 1.5 and 3 miles. I promise you rucking is not the best way to get there. You will be much better served by getting your quality E and HIC work from running and only running.
I assume I’ll reach a lower bpm when rucking (even with 50lbs), since it’s flat terrain?
Doubtful. 50lbs is not considered a heavy load, but it's far from easy. It sounds like you are determined to stay in LSS country (120-150 bpm...conversational pace...whatever). What happens if your ruck load doesn't let you stay there? Yeah you can slow down, but 50lbs is 50lbs...the weight doesn't care what you want your heart rate to be. With running, it's easy to get your heart rate down (even you have to walk).
Under what circumstances do you use rucking?
When I have an operational need to be in "ruck shape." There is almost zero chance I will have to carry a ruck in the near future. So I am not rucking at all right now. I will have to pick it up again at some point.
Some folks find that rucking improves their run time. To me it's more of the reverse - the more I run, the better my rucking gets. It's a great way to get in some miles to change things up as well as improving posture and strength in your torso provided you keep good posture as you're rucking. If you have any kind of aspirations to go into the military and/or do a selection course, it's definitely a good idea to use. If not, it's not as important.ml1985 wrote:Sorry for bumping this thread... Currently doing BB and I have a 60 minute run planned this evening, but I’m considering rucking instead. Does rucking achieves the same results as a LSS run (assuming my long term goals are improving my 1.5 mile and 5K run)? I assume I’ll reach a lower bpm when rucking (even with 50lbs), since it’s flat terrain? Under what circumstances do you use rucking?