Smith machines: how bad are they?
Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 9:40 pm
I've been using the gym in the basement of the building where I work, which has limited me in a few ways. While there are benches, there is no barbell and no squat rack. Only a smith machine and an EZcurl bar.
I'd read a few places that smith machines limit your movement, which can isolate what you actually get to improve on, which can cause injuries down the road. My current way around this has been to use the ezcurl for OHP rather than BP and Zercher squats rather than back squats for a Fighter cluster of Zercher/OHP/PU/DL.
And I've loved it! OHP is fun, and I've grown to really love how much zerchers work you over. But as I finish up this block, I've started wondering if I should switch to BP and back squat for the next block. Normally I'd assume it's a great idea if it weren't for the fact that both changes would require using the smith machine over free weights.
So I'd love to hear people's thoughts on how detrimental that could actually be. I know the smith machine gets demonized a lot, but I'm not sure how much of that is based on evidence and how much is based on the general dislike of using any sort of "machine" over free weights. I'm also not sure if alternating blocks means zerchers would shore up any weakness in stability that I might get from using a smith machine to squat.
I'd read a few places that smith machines limit your movement, which can isolate what you actually get to improve on, which can cause injuries down the road. My current way around this has been to use the ezcurl for OHP rather than BP and Zercher squats rather than back squats for a Fighter cluster of Zercher/OHP/PU/DL.
And I've loved it! OHP is fun, and I've grown to really love how much zerchers work you over. But as I finish up this block, I've started wondering if I should switch to BP and back squat for the next block. Normally I'd assume it's a great idea if it weren't for the fact that both changes would require using the smith machine over free weights.
So I'd love to hear people's thoughts on how detrimental that could actually be. I know the smith machine gets demonized a lot, but I'm not sure how much of that is based on evidence and how much is based on the general dislike of using any sort of "machine" over free weights. I'm also not sure if alternating blocks means zerchers would shore up any weakness in stability that I might get from using a smith machine to squat.