nickgoldma wrote:Good idea. What about an actual horizontal row machine where you sit and pull the weight? (Not to be confused with a rower).
I don't actually know. My hypothesis is that it would, but would be less effective. My starting point in strength training was in calisthenics, and particularly from the mindset of manipulating leverages. So I started learning the pull-up by strengthening my lats from vertical pulls, then lowering towards horizontal rows, then elevated row, chin ups, neutral chins, then finally a pull-up.
The logic was that the pull-up is a full body exercise - and it is. I find that the tighter I can get my entire body, from my lats, to neck, down to abs, glutes, and legs, the more efficient and stronger my pull-up. Hence I recommend horizontal rows and it's progression to pull-ups.
I think a rowing machine will help, but you'd have to then learn how to tense and tighten your body and activate your stabiliser (
which won't be as engaged in a rowing machine). I suppose it'll help as an assistance exercise, but I'll reiterate that I don't know about its efficiency as a starting point to train the pull-ups.